Get Permission Godse, Gosavi, Karande, and Nawathe: Examining the relationship between medical doctors' lifestyle behaviors and the incidence of lifestyle-related diseases: An observational cohort study


Introduction

Healthy habits among physicians are crucial for guiding patients towards preventing chronic diseases. General practitioners (GPs) serve as health role models and are more inclined to advise patients on lifestyle behavior change if the GP themselves follow healthy habits. Practicing what they preach is a significant factor influencing physicians' ability to counsel patients effectively on health promotion.1 Currently, a “healthy lifestyle” is defined as engaging in sufficient physical activity, having a well-balanced diet, a Body Mass Index (BMI) within the recommended range, a non or moderate consumption of alcohol, being a non-smoker and obtaining sufficient daily sleep.2 Despite the established criteria for a "healthy lifestyle," a study in the southern region of India revealed that among 240 doctors surveyed, 54% (114) were overweight or obese. Additionally, 54.5% of doctors reported low levels of physical activity.3 Doctors and nurses play a pivotal role in ensuring the well-being of patients by delivering essential healthcare services. It's crucial for health care workers to prioritize their own health. Yet, due to the nature of their work, many doctors and nurses lead predominantly sedentary lifestyles, which can inadvertently place them at higher risk for cardiovascular diseases (CVDs) when preventive health measures aren't consistently followed by them. A longitudinal study spanning two decades in Brazil examined various healthcare professionals, revealing concerning trends such as notable weight gain and a notable rise in the occurrence of systemic arterial hypertension and also reported an increased prevalence of dyslipidemia and excessive alcohol consumption among doctors and nurses. These findings signify the importance of promoting healthier habits within the healthcare community to safeguard their wellbeing.4 Another study carried out in Singapore to estimate the prevalence of cardiovascular risk factors among health workers (doctors and nurses) reported that around 10% of the doctors and nurses were having dyslipidemia, and around 7% of them were obese (body mass index >30 kg/m2). 5 India is one among the epicenters of Diabetes Mellitus (DM) pandemic worldwide. The sharp rise in the prevalence of DM in India has likely been caused by quick demographic shift and socioeconomic advancement.6, 7 The results from a study concluded that 29.7% of the medical doctors who were assessed had an increased 10 year risk of type 2 diabetes mellitus [34]. According to a study conducted in Tamil Nadu India, reported prevalence of Diabetes mellitus (25.4%),Hypertension(29.4%), overweight (36.5%) ,obesity (15.1%).8

According to several recent study, hours of sleep among physicians averaged between 5.9 h and 6.5 h of daily sleep.9 Insufficient sleep proved to be associated with decreased performance, increased stress and burnout, and higher risk of obesity, diabetes and hypertension.10 There is research that risky behaviours such as consuming alcohol, using tobacco, and eating unhealthy have a correlation and frequently occur together or in groups in most of the physicians.11 The World Health Organisation (WHO) recommends that people should engage in doing moderate to intense exercise for 150 minutes of or at least strenuous exercise for 75 minutes of per week.12 However, evidence points to a low Physical Activity (PA) level among physicians. In Cameroon, primary healthcare providers (PHCPs) participated in a study that revealed 86% of them did not maintain the necessary physical activity level.13 Similarly, a cross-sectional survey conducted in Bahrain revealed that only 29.6% of doctors exercised for at least 30 minutes per week, and only 13% reported physical activity for at least five days per week.14 Even with the increasing positive evidence regarding the benefits of physical activity (PA) and the consensus among healthcare professionals (HCPs) on the importance of promoting PA to patients, studies reveal that numerous physicians do not actively engage in such promotion , moreover, despite the crucial nature of this matter, few studies have investigated the health-promoting lifestyle profile (HPLP) among medical doctors.15

Assessing the presence of health-related lifestyle factors among physicians is essential, as healthy behaviors may not only significantly reduce mortality and morbidity but will also have a notable impact on counselling of their patients In order to determine whether medical doctors who themselves counsel patients to lead healthy lifestyles also adhere to that advice in their daily lives, this study was conducted with an objective to assess the lifestyle behaviours of medical doctors (consultants, non-clinical physicians, resident medical assistants, and post-graduate medical students) of tertiary care centers with a view of investigating this topic and educating doctors about health promoting behavior and practices.

Methods and Materials

This was a prospective, observational, single center study conducted from April 2023 to June 2023 at the department of Pulmonology and Sleep Medicine of Bhaktivedanta Hospital and Research Institute, Thane, India. This study was approved by the Institutional Ethics Committee (IEC) and has been registered with CTRI (CTRI/2023/03/051184). Considering the confidence level of 95% and relative precision of 307.56, a total sample size of 146 doctors were calculated.

The study started post obtaining non-objection certification by Director of the institute. All the doctors of the institute were briefly explained about the objective of the study, and consequently a questionnaire through google form were circulated online which had additionally a consent form incorporating the details of purpose of the study and a permission to use their respective data in the study. The form was designed with questions regarding their demographic details, details of comorbid conditions, family history of comorbid condition, duration and nature of physical activity, their dietary habits, sleep habits, smoking habits and questions regarding alcohol use were also asked, the questionnaire was well validated and approved by EC. Out of all doctors, a total of 74 doctors filled the questionnaire, for whom physical assessments were conducted within 20 days of filling of the questionnaires, the physical assessment involved evaluation of height, weight, BMI, SpO2 (%), BP, body fat, subcutaneous fat, visceral fat. Measurements of circumference of neck, waist, and hip.

The numeric data were summarized by descriptive statistics like n, mean ± SD, median, minimum, and maximum. Before applying any statistical test, a normality test was performed. The categorical data were summarized by frequency count, and percentage and significance were analyzed using the chi-square test. All statistical data was analyzed by IBM SPSS software v.23.0. A p-value less than 0.05 was considered statistically significant.

Results

In our study out of 74 physicians, 32 (43%) individuals were male, while 42 (57%) were female, with most common age group being 36 to 45 years (50%) 25 to 35 years (30%), 46 to 55 years (15%), and 56 to 65 years (5%) (Figure 1, Figure 2)

In terms of dietary habits, 46 (62.16%) were vegetarian, whereas 28 (37.84%) were non-vegetarian. Regarding physical activity (PA) levels, 60 (81.08%) participants of the sample, engaged in ≥ 150 minutes of PA per week, while 14 (18.92%) participants, reported engaging in ≤ 150 minutes of PA per week (Figure 3). However, no significant association was observed between physical activity and visceral fat (p-value = 0.38), nor between physical activity and body fat composition (p-value = 0.57) (Table 1).

Sleep patterns were categorized as disturbed, in 51 (68.92%) participants, and undisturbed, in 23 (31.08%) participants. In our study, 17 individuals (22.97%) received sufficient sunlight exposure, while 57 individuals (77.03%) did not receive adequate sunlight exposure. Additionally, alcohol consumption was reported by 9 (12.16%) participants, and tobacco consumption was reported by 3 (4.05%) participants (Figure 3).

The present study did not find any statistically significant correlation between diet and visceral fat (p- value = 0.583), nor between diet and body fat composition (p-value = 0.499). Similarly, our analysis revealed no significant association between sleep and visceral fat (p-value = 0.77), as well as between sleep and body fat (p-value = 0.674) (Table 1)

The correlation between visceral fat and BMI across different diet groups was observed. For participants following a vegetarian diet, the correlation coefficient (r value) is reported at 0.539 with a corresponding p-value of less than 0.0001, indicating a significant correlation. Conversely, in the non-vegetarian diet group, the correlation coefficient stands at 0.564, with a p-value of 0.002, also indicating a significant correlation. These findings suggest that both vegetarian and non-vegetarian dietary patterns exhibit notable correlations between visceral fat levels and BMI, highlighting the importance of diet in relation to body composition and health outcomes. (Table 2)

Figure 1

Gender wise distribution

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/f5dda662-b465-4525-982f-a3a58db6c324image1.png
Figure 2

Age wise distribution

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/f5dda662-b465-4525-982f-a3a58db6c324image2.png
Figure 3

Lifestyle characteristics and habits

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/f5dda662-b465-4525-982f-a3a58db6c324image3.png
Table 1

Association of various factors affecting the visceral fat and body fat composition.

Variables

Value

df

Asymptotic Significance (2-sided)

Exact Sig. (1-sided)

Corelation between Diet and Visceral Fat Association

Pearson Chi-Square

.005a

1

.943

Continuity Correctionb

.000

1

1.000

Likelihood Ratio

.005

1

.943

Fisher's Exact Test

.583

Corelation between Diet and Body Fat Association

Pearson Chi-Square

.330a

1

.566

Continuity Correction b

.000

1

1.000

Likelihood Ratio

.293

1

.589

Fisher's Exact Test

.499

Corelation between physical activity and Visceral Fat Association

Pearson Chi-Square

.342a

1

.559

.383

Continuity Correction b

.095

1

.758

Likelihood Ratio

.347

1

.556

.383

Fisher's Exact Test

.383

Corelation between physical activity and body Fat Association

Pearson Chi-Square

.138a

1

.710

.572

Continuity Correction b

.000

1

1.000

Likelihood Ratio

.129

1

.720

.572

Fisher's Exact Test

.572

Corelation between sleep and Visceral Fat Association

Pearson Chi-Square

3.246a

1

.072

.077

Continuity Correction b

2.066

1

.151

Likelihood Ratio

3.168

1

.075

.077

Fisher's Exact Test

.077

Corelation between sleep and Body Fat Association

Pearson Chi-Square

.433a

1

.511

.674

Continuity Correction b

.000

1

1.000

Likelihood Ratio

.795

1

.372

.674

Fisher's Exact Test

.674

Table 2

Correlation between Visceral Fat and BMI in diet groups

Groups

Parameters

Vegetarian diet group

r Value

P Value

0.539

<0.0001

Non-vegetarian diet group

0.564

0.002

Discussion

The demanding nature of medical work can also take a toll on doctors' physical health.16 According to a recent study conducted in India to evaluate the prevalence of metabolic syndrome in physicians, it was observed that there were significantly higher metabolic syndrome rates among females than in males.17 The results of the present study shows a lower prevalence of hypertension (12.1%), diabetes (5.4%) among physicians However, a study carried out on the lifestyle habits and well-being of physicians in middle-east India in 2015 reported a higher prevalence of hypertension (20.3%) and diabetes (11%). 18 One possible reason for the increased prevalence of lifestyle disorders among doctors could be the demanding nature of their profession, which often leads to irregular working hours, high stress levels, and limited time for self-care activities such as exercise and healthy eating which can contribute to increased risks of obesity, cardiovascular disease, and other health problems.19

Research on physicians' BMI, which indicated that around one-third of every 10 physicians were either overweight or obese.19 In our study, a significant negative correlation was obtained between physical activity and Body fat association and visceral fat (Table 1). In our study, 31 (41.8%) physicians were overweight whereas 14 (8.9%) physicians were obese which aligns to a study done on predictors of obesity among postgraduate trainee doctors, which observed that the prevalence of overweight was 31.6% and obesity was 28.2%.20 The results of the current study also aligns with a study conducted among doctors at the University of Brunei Darussalam, in which the prevalence of overweight and obesity was found to be 37% and 17%, respectively. 19 Additionally, patients of overweight and obese doctors are less likely to follow their doctors' medical recommendations than patients of doctors who are of a healthy weight.21

A study carried out about dietary habits among health-care professionals in Saudi Arabia reported a high percentage of participants who regularly ate dairy foods (74%), meat (91%), and sweet foods (60%) and drank carbonated beverages with sugar (55%) and alcohol (65%). Most participants rarely ate fruits (77%) and vegetables (73%).22 In another survey carried out on the dietary habits of medical students, states that only 13 participants (10%) had fruit consumption.21 The results of this studies were inconsistent with our findings wherein 41 (55%) have 1 to 6 teaspoon refined sugar whereas 33 (44.5%) have no sugar consumption in their daily life. Whereas only 31.8% participant had soft drinks and beverages in their daily lives. 24.3% eat red meat once in a week and most of the participants were 62.16% were vegetarian (Figure 3) with their diet consisting of vegetables, fruits, whole grains.

In our study there is a significant correlation between visceral fat and BMI with vegetarian diet group participants (p value =<0.0001) (Table 2), which is in similar lines with other cross-sectional studies which also observed a significantly greater reduction in visceral fat and BMI in individuals consuming plant-based diets.23, 24 The survey involved an intervention with a low-fat vegetable-based diet and vegetable meal replacement (intervention group) and an omnivorous diet. The authors observed significant reduction in weight, body fat, and visceral fat in interventional group.25 Our study found a significant correlation between visceral fat and BMI in non-vegetarian group participants (p value = 0.002) (Table 2). The results are in similar lines with studies that found statistically significant differences in body composition and BMI in participants who have vegetable-based and omnivorous diets combined.26

We found that the medical doctors of our tertiary care hospital were sleeping for a lesser time per night (6.3 [6.0-6.7] hours) than the 7 hours or more, recommended by the American Academy of Sleep Medicine and Sleep Research Society.27 In our study 68.92% of physicians had disturbed sleep (Figure 3). The excessive workload compounded by the inadequate sleep in them can be a threat to the health of both the physician and the patient. Prolonged sleep restriction has been reported to reduce the cognitive and clinical performance of physicians, Further, sleep-deprived doctors are vulnerable to the well-described long-term consequences of chronic sleep loss that include obesity, type II diabetes mellitus, and increased cardiovascular diseases. However, in our study we found no statistically significant association between sleep and body fat and visceral fat (Table 2).

The limitation of the current study, is its study design which is single centric conducted at a tertiary care centre. A multi-centric study with a larger sample size catering to a heterogenous population could have been more reliable. The questionnaire used in the study is elaborate which could be a reason for recall bias by the physicians given the time constraint.

Conclusion

  1. It's crucial for doctors to intrinsically motivate themselves to adopt healthy lifestyles, not only for their own professional well-being but also as advocates for promoting overall physical and psychological health within society.

  2. Our findings align with numerous other studies, emphasizing the necessity for a carefully devised strategy to address financial and technological barriers hindering the accurate identification of health risk factors and the implementation of corrective interventions.

  3. It is imperative to integrate healthy dietary habits and regular exercise into daily routines. Notably, half of the doctors reported experiencing insomnia due to their extensive professional commitments. Certain dietary patterns, levels of physical activity, and lifestyle choices appear to correlate with the demanding schedules and prolonged working hours commonly experienced in the medical profession.

Source of Funding

None.

Conflict of Interest

None.

References

1 

SM Ahmed A Hadi A Razzaque A Ashraf S Juvekar N Ng Clustering of chronic non-communicable disease risk factors among selected Asian populations: levels and determinants. Glob Health Action19862826875

2 

W Miron R Malatskey L Rosen Health-related behaviours and perceptions among physicians: results from a cross-sectional study in IsraelBMJ Open20199931353

3 

A Nair T Lawrence P Indu Obesity burden and physical activity pattern among doctors in South IndiaIndian J Occup Environ Med20222642615

4 

TV Jardim A Sousa TR Povoa WS Barroso B Chinem PCV Jardim Comparison of Cardiovascular Risk Factors in Different Areas of Health Care Over a 20-Year PeriodArquivos Brasileiros de Cardiologia20141036493501

5 

L Leong Prevalence of cardiovascular risk factors among healthcare staff in a large healthcare institution in SingaporeSingapore Med J201253851721

6 

R Unnikrishnan RM Anjana V Mohan Diabetes mellitus and its complications in IndiaNat Rev Endocrinol201612635770

7 

R Unnikrishnan R Pradeepa SR Joshi V Mohan Type 2 Diabetes: Demystifying the Global EpidemicDiab2017666143274

8 

SKB Hegde S Sathiyanarayanan S Venkateshwaran Prevalence of Diabetes, Hypertension and Obesity among Doctors and Nurses in a Medical College Hospital in Tamil NaduIndia Nat J Res Commun Med2015432359

9 

Y Wu F Jiang S Wu Y Liu YL Tang Sleep duration and satisfaction among physicians in tertiary public hospitals in China: a large sample national surveyJ Occup Med Toxicol20211618

10 

HR Colten BM Altevogt Extent and Health Consequences of Chronic Sleep Loss and Sleep DisorderNational Academies PressUS)2006199

11 

AA Mohd A Lai H Parveen SK Ong Prevalence of overweight and obesity among doctors in Brunei DarussalamBrunei Int Med J201612412733

12 

World Health Organization. Physical activity. www.who.int.2023https://www.who.int/initiatives/behealthy/physical-activity

13 

M Alyafei M Alchawa A Farooq N Selim I Bougmiza Physical Activity among Primary Health Care Physicians and Its Impact on Counseling PracticesBiomed Hub2023813141

14 

SM Borgan GA Jassim ZA Marhoon MH Ibrahim The lifestyle habits and wellbeing of physicians in Bahrain: a cross-sectional studyBMC Public Health201515655

15 

FA Albert MJ Crowe A Malau-Aduli M Aduli Bs Physical Activity Promotion: A Systematic Review of The Perceptions of Healthcare ProfessionalsInt J Environ Res Public Health202017124358

16 

A Koinis V Giannou V Drantaki S Angelaina E Stratou M Saridi The Impact of Healthcare Workers Job Environment on Their mental-emotional health. Coping strategies: the Case of a Local General Hospital. Health Psychology ResearchHealth Psychol Res2015131137

17 

DS Prasad Z Kabir AK Dash BC Das Prevalence and risk factors for metabolic syndrome in Asian Indians: A community study from urban Eastern IndiaJ Cardiovascular Dis Res20123320415

18 

R Garg P Agrawal AP Singh M Agrawal P Gupta Glimpse into the Lifestyle of DoctorsJ Mid-Life Health202213211535

19 

S Mahmood R Najjad N Ali Predictors of obesity among post graduate trainee doctors working in a tertiary care hospital of public sector in KarachiJ Pak Med Assoc201060975861

20 

SH Kunene NP Taukobong Dietary habits among health professionals working in a district hospitalAfr J Pri Health Care Fam Med20179115KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa

21 

AM Pinto T Sanders AC Kendall A Nicolaou R Gray H Al-Khatib A comparison of heart rate variability, n-3 PUFA status and lipid mediator profile in age- and BMI-matched middle-aged vegans and omnivoresBrit J Nutr2017117566985

22 

N Vibhute R Baad U Belgaumi V Kadashetti S Bommanavar W Kamate Dietary habits amongst medical students: An institution-based studyJournal of Family Medicine and Primary Care20187614641464

23 

F Sofi M Dinu G Pagliai F Cesari A M Gori A Sereni Low-Calorie Vegetarian Versus Mediterranean Diets for Reducing Body Weight and Improving Cardiovascular Risk Profile: CARDIVEG Study (Cardiovascular Prevention With Vegetarian Diet)Circulation20181371111036

24 

A Brytek-Matera Interaction between Vegetarian Versus Omnivorous Diet and Unhealthy Eating Patterns (Orthorexia Nervosa, Cognitive Restraint) and Body Mass Index in AdultsNutrients2020123646

25 

L Shaik MS Cheema S Subramanian R Kashyap SR Surani Sleep and Safety among Healthcare Workers: The Effect of Obstructive Sleep Apnea and Sleep Deprivation on SafetyMedicina (Kaunas)202258121723

26 

A Priya E Tharion Sleep and Exercise among Young Doctors in a Tertiary Care Hospital in India: A Pilot Cross-Sectional StudyJ Lifestyle Med202212316470

27 

L Shaik M S Cheema S Subramanian R Kashyap S R Surani Sleep and Safety among Healthcare Workers: The Effect of Obstructive Sleep Apnea and Sleep Deprivation on Safety20225817231723



jats-html.xsl


This is an Open Access (OA) journal, and articles are distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 License, which allows others to remix, tweak, and build upon the work non-commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given and the new creations are licensed under the identical terms.

  • Article highlights
  • Article tables
  • Article images

Article History

Received : 13-04-2024

Accepted : 27-06-2024


View Article

PDF File   Full Text Article


Copyright permission

Get article permission for commercial use

Downlaod

PDF File   XML File   ePub File


Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

Article DOI

https://doi.org/ 10.18231/j.sajhp.2024.023


Article Metrics






Article Access statistics

Viewed: 114

PDF Downloaded: 10